There was no perfect ending to the surprising run of the New York Red Bulls through the Major League Soccer Playoffs. They worked their way to the MLS Cup, but there was no more magic left - the Columbus Crew kept them grounded. The Crew was the best team during the regular season came out with the teams first ever MLS Cup with a 3-1 victory over the New York Red Bulls.

 Alejandro Mereno, of the Crew, scored the first goal of the match in the 31st minute, slipping a tight-angled shot past Danny Cepero, the Red Bulls goalkeeper. The Red Bulls didn't stop attacking, and evened the score with a goal by John Wolyniec early in the second half. The score didn't stay 1-1 for buy 87 seconds when a Schelotto corner kick was headed in by Chad Marshall to but the Crew up 2-1. Later in the 82nd minute the Crew added some padding to there lead. Frankie Hejduk scored the goal giving Schelotto his third assist in the game.

A well deserving Schelotto was name the MLS Cup Most Valuable Player finishing the game with three assists. This makes him the third player in MLS history to win the league MVP and the MLS Cup Finals MVP honors. A fitting end to a great season for both Schelotto and the Columbus Crew.